Overview
Welsh law has developed through several major historical and constitutional stages. Medieval Wales had its own rulers, political structures and legal traditions. Following English conquest and later Acts of Parliament, Wales became increasingly integrated into the English legal system.
Centuries later, devolution transferred important decision-making and law-making powers back to Wales. The Senedd and Welsh Ministers can now create a growing body of law that applies specifically in Wales. However, Wales still forms part of the single legal jurisdiction of England and Wales.
Medieval Wales and the Statute of Rhuddlan
Medieval Wales was not permanently united under one ruler. Instead, it consisted of different kingdoms, principalities and lordships whose rulers competed for influence and control.
One of the most powerful Welsh kingdoms was Gwynedd, located in north-west Wales. During the thirteenth century, its ruler Llywelyn ap Gruffudd became powerful enough to exercise authority over much of Wales. In 1267, King Henry III of England formally recognised him as Prince of Wales. However, this period of wider Welsh unity was relatively short-lived.
Wales also had its own legal traditions. An important example was Cyfraith Hywel, or the Law of Hywel, which was associated with the tenth-century Welsh ruler Hywel Dda. Welsh law developed over several centuries and dealt with areas including property, family relationships, crime and disputes.
The position changed significantly following the military campaigns of Edward I. After the defeat of the native Welsh princes in 1282–83, the English Crown gained direct control over large parts of Wales.
The Statute of Rhuddlan 1284, also known as the Statute of Wales, then established a new system for governing the Welsh territories under the direct control of the English Crown. It was a law issued through royal authority rather than an Act passed by Parliament.
The Statute introduced an English-style system of administration and replaced Welsh criminal law with English criminal law in the territories it governed. However, important parts of Welsh civil law and custom continued to operate, particularly in areas such as land, inheritance and family law.
The Statute therefore did not immediately replace every aspect of Welsh law. Instead, it created a mixed legal system in the territories controlled directly by the Crown. Other parts of Wales, particularly the Marcher lordships along the border and in parts of southern Wales, remained outside this particular system.
Sources used4 sources
The Laws in Wales Acts and the Courts of Great Sessions
A much greater change occurred during the reign of Henry VIII.
The Laws in Wales Acts 1535 and 1542 brought Wales more fully within the legal, political and administrative structures of England. English law was extended across Wales, the Marcher lordships were reorganised, new counties were created and Wales gained representation in the English Parliament.
The Acts effectively ended the formal use of native Welsh law within the legal system established by the Crown. From this point, English law became the law formally administered throughout Wales.
However, Wales was given a distinctive court system known as the Courts of Great Sessions. These were courts operating specifically in Wales which dealt with both serious criminal cases and important civil disputes.
This created an interesting position. Wales had its own regional court structure, but those courts applied English law rather than a separate body of Welsh law.
The Courts of Great Sessions remained in place for almost three centuries. However, they were eventually abolished by the Law Terms Act 1830.
Following their abolition, the jurisdiction of the central courts was extended into Wales and Wales became part of the Wales and Chester Circuit. A circuit was a regional arrangement through which judges travelled to different areas to hear cases.
This brought the administration of justice in Wales more closely into the same court structure used in England, removing one of the last major institutional differences between the two countries.
Sources used4 sources
Statutory treatment of Wales and the Welsh language
The legal integration of Wales with England can also be seen in the way Parliament historically referred to the two countries.
The Wales and Berwick Act 1746 provided that references to “England” in Acts of Parliament would generally be understood as including Wales and Berwick-upon-Tweed, unless the legislation indicated otherwise.
Berwick-upon-Tweed may appear unusual in this context. It is a town close to the modern border between England and Scotland and had changed between English and Scottish control several times during its history. Its unusual historical position meant that legislation sometimes referred to it specifically to remove uncertainty about which laws applied there.
The 1746 Act reflected how closely Wales had become legally integrated with England. However, the approach later changed. The Welsh Language Act 1967 distinguished Wales from England for the interpretation of future legislation. The Wales and Berwick Act was eventually repealed completely by the Interpretation Act 1978, although special rules remain for interpreting references to England in some older legislation.
Another important development concerned the use of the Welsh language in the courts.
The Welsh Courts Act 1942 removed an earlier legal restriction and allowed Welsh to be used by a party or witness in a court in Wales where that person considered that they would otherwise be at a disadvantage because Welsh was their natural language of communication. It also allowed arrangements to be made for interpreters.
The Welsh Language Act 1967 went further. It provided that Welsh could be spoken in legal proceedings in Wales by any party, witness or other person who wished to use it, subject to procedural requirements in some courts.
The Welsh Language Act 1993 developed the position further by placing the principle of treating Welsh and English on a basis of equality into the statutory framework governing public business and the administration of justice in Wales.
These developments were significant because they gradually removed legal barriers to the use of Welsh and gave the language a stronger position within public and legal life in Wales.
Sources used5 sources
Devolution and the National Assembly for Wales
The next major stage in the development of Welsh law began with devolution.
Devolution is the transfer of certain powers from the UK Parliament and Government to institutions in another part of the United Kingdom.
Following the 1997 Welsh devolution referendum, Parliament passed the Government of Wales Act 1998. This created the legal framework for the National Assembly for Wales, which began operating in 1999 as a democratically elected institution for Wales.
However, its original powers were much more limited than those of the modern Senedd.
The Assembly could not initially pass its own Acts. Instead, it mainly made subordinate legislation, also known as secondary legislation. This means detailed law made using powers that have already been granted by primary legislation, such as an Act of the UK Parliament.
The Assembly could use these powers in areas where responsibilities had been transferred to Wales, including areas such as health, education, local government and economic development. The UK Parliament, however, continued to pass the main primary legislation for Wales.
The Government of Wales Act 1998 therefore created an important foundation for Welsh devolution, but it did not create the powerful law-making parliament that exists today.
The original Assembly was also established as a single corporate body. In simple terms, the law did not formally create a clear separation between the Assembly and a separate Welsh Government.
This meant that the institution responsible for representing Wales and scrutinising decisions was not legally separated from the executive functions involved in carrying out policy and administering government.
Sources used3 sources
The Government of Wales Act 2006 and the 2011 referendum
The Government of Wales Act 2006 significantly changed the structure and powers created by the 1998 Act.
One major change was the formal separation of the legislature from the executive.
The legislature was the National Assembly for Wales, whose role included making laws, representing the people of Wales and scrutinising the government. The executive consisted of Welsh Ministers responsible for making policy, running government and carrying out the law.
The 2006 Act also introduced a new form of Welsh primary legislation known as Assembly Measures.
However, the Assembly could only pass a Measure where it had legislative competence. Legislative competence simply means the legal authority to make legislation about a particular matter.
One way of gaining additional law-making authority was through a Legislative Competence Order, commonly shortened to LCO.
An LCO was a legal mechanism that could give the Assembly authority to make Measures on a particular subject. The process required approval from the Assembly and both Houses of the UK Parliament before the additional power could be granted. Acts passed at Westminster could also give further legislative powers directly to the Assembly.
This meant that the Assembly's law-making powers were growing, but gaining additional powers could still require the involvement of the UK Parliament.
The position changed significantly following the 2011 referendum.
The referendum gave the Assembly broader primary law-making powers across the devolved subjects for which it already had responsibility. It could now pass Acts of the Assembly without having to obtain separate approval from Westminster for each new area of legislation through the LCO process.
However, Wales still operated under what was known as a conferred-powers model.
Under this model, the Assembly could make laws only on subjects where law-making powers had specifically been given, or conferred, to Wales. If a subject had not been transferred, the Assembly could not legislate on it.
Sources used3 sources
The Wales Act 2017 and the reserved-powers model
The Wales Act 2017 introduced another major change to Welsh devolution by replacing the conferred-powers model with a reserved-powers model.
The new system came into force on 1 April 2018.
Under the reserved-powers model, the starting point is that the Senedd can legislate unless the subject has been specifically reserved to the UK Parliament, although its powers remain subject to other legal limits.
This reversed the basic approach of the previous system. Under the conferred-powers model, Wales needed specific authority to legislate. Under the reserved-powers model, the Senedd generally has law-making authority unless a matter has been specifically kept at Westminster.
The Wales Act 2017 also declared the National Assembly for Wales and the Welsh Government to be permanent parts of the United Kingdom's constitutional arrangements. However, the Act did not remove the principle of parliamentary sovereignty, meaning that the UK Parliament remains legally capable of passing legislation for Wales.
A number of important subjects also remain reserved to Westminster. These include many areas relating to policing, courts and the wider justice system.
Importantly, the 2017 reforms also formally recognised that there is a body of Welsh law made by the Senedd and Welsh Ministers. However, this Welsh law continues to form part of the wider law of England and Wales rather than belonging to a completely separate Welsh legal jurisdiction.
Sources used3 sources
Senedd Cymru and the Welsh Parliament
As the Assembly gained greater law-making and political powers, its original name became less representative of the institution it had developed into.
The Senedd and Elections (Wales) Act 2020 changed the name of the National Assembly for Wales to Senedd Cymru or Welsh Parliament, commonly known simply as the Senedd.
The change took effect on 6 May 2020.
The new name reflected how much the institution had developed since 1999. What began as an Assembly with limited secondary law-making powers had developed into a national parliament capable of passing primary legislation within its areas of responsibility.
Today, Wales therefore has a growing and distinct body of Welsh law created by the Senedd and Welsh Ministers.
However, this does not mean that Wales currently has its own separate legal jurisdiction. Welsh law continues to form part of the law of England and Wales, and the two countries remain within the same legal jurisdiction.
This creates an important feature of the modern legal system: England and Wales share one jurisdiction, but laws applying in the two countries can increasingly differ because of Welsh devolution.
Sources used2 sources