Bloodstone opens Vardarax’s public beta with a new crimson mountain identity, refreshed information pages and editable homepage links. It carries forward the learning materials and reading tools established by Stark and Obsidian.
Project Obsidian transformed Vardarax, arguably more than any future project will. It built on the foundations laid by Project Stark, redesigned the user interface and introduced new features and interactive systems. It reimagined how people use Vardarax, from finding their way around the site to working through its learning materials.
Stark gave Vardarax its first shape: a place to find a course, follow a topic and read with the sources close at hand. Its foundations continue to support the learning experience today.
Explains how the stronger monarchy described in Note 1 developed into a wider system of royal justice. It examines the period before Henry II, Henry II's reforms, itinerant justices, the Assize of Clarendon, writs, Magna Carta and the emergence of the central common-law courts. It also explains the historical meaning of common law, the much later development of binding precedent and the procedural limitations that helped prepare the way for equity.
Last updated: 24 August 2026Last checked against sources: 24 August 20263,806 words18 min read
Note 1 ended by showing that William I strengthened the Crown without creating English common law or abolishing local courts and customs. This note follows the gradual expansion of justice administered in the king's name.
During the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, royal officials travelled more regularly through the country, recognised procedures allowed more disputes to enter the king's courts and permanent judicial institutions developed at Westminster. Together, these changes produced a body of royal law that could operate across much of England.
Stronger royal government after 1066
↓
Royal justice reaches more parts of England
↓
Shared courts and procedures develop
↓
A recognisable English common law emerges
Royal Government Before Henry II
William II and Henry I
William II, also known as William Rufus, ruled from 1087 to 1100. He maintained the powerful monarchy inherited from William I, but his reign is not usually treated as a major turning point in the formation of common law.
More significant administrative developments occurred under Henry I, who ruled from 1100 to 1135.
Henry strengthened royal government by relying on officials who could conduct business in the king's absence. Financial administration became more organised, and royal officials and judges were increasingly able to carry the king's authority beyond the royal household.
These developments did not create common law by themselves. They did, however, make royal government more regular and gave later kings stronger administrative foundations on which to build.
The Charter of Liberties 1100
Soon after taking the throne, Henry I issued the Charter of Liberties, also called his Coronation Charter.
The Charter promised to end or limit several practices associated with the previous reign. Its provisions dealt mainly with the Church, inheritance, reliefs, wardship, marriage and other relationships between the Crown and important landholders.
It was not a modern bill of rights and did not establish equal legal rights for the whole population. It was an accession document through which Henry sought political support by promising to govern certain matters more lawfully and moderately.
Its later importance lies partly in the example it provided. When opposition to King John developed in the early thirteenth century, Henry's Charter offered an earlier model of written promises intended to restrain particular uses of royal power. It is therefore commonly regarded as a forerunner of Magna Carta 1215.
The White Ship and the Anarchy
On 25 November 1120, the White Ship sank while crossing the English Channel. Among those who died was William Adelin, Henry I's only legitimate son and expected male heir.
Henry later designated his legitimate daughter Matilda as his successor. She was known as Empress Matilda because of her earlier marriage to the Holy Roman Emperor Henry V. Leading nobles swore to recognise her claim.
When Henry died in 1135, however, his nephew Stephen of Blois secured the throne. Matilda and her supporters continued to press her claim, and the resulting conflict became known as the Anarchy.
The name can be misleading if it suggests that every part of England experienced continuous disorder. Nevertheless, royal authority weakened significantly in several regions, while powerful landholders acquired greater freedom to exercise local military and political control.
Stephen was captured at the Battle of Lincoln in 1141, but Matilda did not secure a coronation and Stephen later recovered his position. By the 1150s, Matilda's son, Henry of Anjou, had become the principal challenger.
In 1153, Stephen and Henry reached a settlement commonly associated with the Treaty of Wallingford. Stephen remained king, but Henry was recognised as his successor. When Stephen died in 1154, Henry became Henry II.
The legal importance of the Anarchy lies mainly in its effect on royal authority. Henry II inherited strong reasons to restore the Crown's control and to make royal government and justice operate more effectively throughout England.
Sources used7 sources
Lucy Jones, Introduction to Business Law (6th edn, Oxford University Press 2025) ch 1
Henry II, the son of Empress Matilda and Geoffrey of Anjou, ruled England from 1154 to 1189.
His reign is one of the most important periods in the history of English common law.
Henry inherited a kingdom that already possessed royal justice, local courts, customary law and experienced administrators. He did not create English law from nothing, and many of the methods used during his reign had earlier foundations.
His importance lies in the scale and organisation of the changes. Henry restored royal authority after Stephen's reign and greatly increased the regular reach of the king's justice.
Royal judges travelled through the country, new or improved procedures made the king's courts attractive to litigants and central judicial work became more specialised. The Crown also asserted greater control over serious crime.
These developments gradually reduced the extent to which access to justice depended entirely on the law and institutions of one locality.
What Did Common Law Mean?
In this historical context, common law refers to law administered through the king's courts that became increasingly common to the realm.
This description should be used carefully. It does not mean that every local custom disappeared or that one complete written code immediately applied in every case. Manorial, local and Church courts continued to exist.
Instead, a growing network of royal judges, courts, writs and procedures made it possible for similar forms of royal justice to operate in different parts of England.
Simple analogy: Local communities continued to have their own routes for resolving disputes, but royal justice began to create a wider national road network connecting them to the same central system.
Sources used6 sources
Lucy Jones, Introduction to Business Law (6th edn, Oxford University Press 2025) ch 1
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
Paul Brand, ‘Henry II and the Creation of the English Common Law’ in Christopher Harper-Bill and Nicholas Vincent (eds), Henry II: New Interpretations (Boydell Press 2007)
John Hudson, The Oxford History of the Laws of England, Volume II: 871–1216 (Oxford University Press 2012)
Itinerant Justices, Circuits and the General Eyre
Royal officials had travelled outside the king's immediate court before Henry II's reign. Henry's government, however, expanded and organised the use of travelling judges.
These judges are commonly described as itinerant justices. Itinerant means travelling from place to place.
They visited counties to conduct legal and administrative business under royal authority. Depending on their commission, they could hear disputes, deal with matters concerning the Crown, inspect local administration and account for money owed to the king.
In 1176, England was divided into six judicial circuits for groups of royal justices.
A circuit was a geographical route or area assigned to judges. Organising travel in this way helped royal justice reach different regions more systematically.
The judges did not simply impose one complete set of rules and immediately erase every local custom. However, their repeated use of royal procedures in different counties encouraged greater consistency and tied local legal activity more closely to central government.
The General Eyre
One important form of travelling royal justice became known as the General Eyre.
A General Eyre was a broad royal visitation of a county. The justices could hear civil and criminal matters, examine pleas affecting the Crown and investigate the conduct of local officials. The eyre therefore combined judicial work with administrative supervision.
Historians trace the institutional beginnings of the General Eyre to the travelling arrangements of Henry II's reign, particularly those of 1176. The earliest surviving eyre roll dates from 1194, after Henry's death.
It is therefore inaccurate both to separate the eyre completely from Henry II's reforms and to suggest that he created its fully developed form through one isolated decision.
Term
Meaning
Itinerant justice
A general description of a royal judge who travelled to conduct judicial business.
Circuit
The geographical route or region assigned to travelling judges.
General Eyre
A wide-ranging periodic visitation in which royal justices heard pleas and examined local administration.
Travelling justice mattered because it extended the Crown's practical reach. It also allowed royal procedures and experience to circulate between the centre and the counties.
Sources used4 sources
Paul Brand, ‘Judges and Judging 1176–1307’ in Paul Brand and Joshua Getzler (eds), Judges and Judging in the History of the Common Law and Civil Law (Cambridge University Press 2012)
The Assize of Clarendon 1166 was an important measure in the expansion of royal criminal justice.
The word assize had several meanings in medieval law. In this context, it refers to a royal measure setting out procedures that were to be followed.
The Assize required inquiries to be made in each county and hundred. Twelve lawful men from each hundred and four lawful men from each township or vill, meaning a local settlement, were placed under oath to identify people publicly suspected of robbery, murder, theft or harbouring those accused of such offences.
These groups were not modern trial juries.
A modern criminal jury hears evidence and decides whether the prosecution has proved guilt. The men used under the Assize instead reported suspected offenders from their own communities. Their function is usually described as presentment.
Simple analogy: They performed an accusing or reporting role, not the modern jury's role of deciding guilt after a trial.
Those presented were taken into custody and subjected to the legal procedures of the period, which included the ordeal of water. The Assize therefore did not introduce the modern criminal trial.
Its importance lay in connecting local knowledge with royal procedure. It also reserved the handling of people presented under the Assize to the king and his justices, thereby increasing the Crown's control over serious wrongdoing.
Procedures involving sworn local groups later contributed to the development of jury institutions. That development was gradual, and the presentment body of 1166 should not be treated as a modern jury under a different name.
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
Writs and Access to the Royal Courts
The growth of royal justice depended on procedures through which a dispute could enter the king's courts.
One of the most important was the writ.
A writ was a formal written command issued in the king's name and authenticated by the royal seal. It could begin or direct legal proceedings by instructing an official or another person to take a specified step.
Different writs were used for different kinds of claim. During and after Henry II's reign, writs became especially important in disputes concerning land.
Examples included procedures relating to:
a person's claimed right to land;
recent dispossession from land; and
the claim of an heir who had been prevented from taking land after an ancestor's death.
Some land procedures used a sworn inquiry, often called a recognition, in which local people answered a defined factual question from their knowledge of the area. Like the presentment procedure used under the Assize of Clarendon, this was an ancestor of later jury practice but was not identical to a modern trial jury.
These procedures did not all ask the same legal question or provide the same route to judgment. The writ selected at the beginning of a case helped determine how the claim would proceed.
Why Writs Mattered
Writs gave litigants recognised routes into royal justice. Similar claims could be processed through recurring procedures, making legal business more regular and predictable.
They also helped the Crown draw disputes away from local and lordly courts and into institutions operating under royal authority.
However, the king's courts were not yet courts of unlimited jurisdiction that could hear every possible grievance. A claimant, meaning the person bringing a civil claim, generally needed a recognised basis for royal intervention and an appropriate procedural route.
Simple analogy: A writ was like an authorised entrance into the royal courts. The number of entrances increased, but a person still needed one that fitted the kind of claim being brought.
The writ system therefore had two connected effects:
It expanded and standardised access to royal justice
but
it also linked legal rights closely to recognised procedures
That second effect later became an important source of rigidity.
Sources used3 sources
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
Lucy Jones, Introduction to Business Law (6th edn, Oxford University Press 2025) ch 1
From the King's Court to Central Royal Courts
Travelling judges extended royal justice into the counties. At the same time, judicial work was becoming more permanent and specialised at the centre of royal government.
An important starting point was the Curia Regis, meaning the King's Court.
The Curia Regis was not one court with a narrowly defined modern jurisdiction. It was part of the machinery of royal government. The king and his advisers dealt with political, administrative, financial and judicial business within the same broad institution.
As the volume and complexity of government increased, particular groups of officials began to specialise.
The Five Judges of 1178
In 1178, Henry II assigned a group of five household officials to concentrate on complaints and other judicial business.
They remained part of the wider royal court and did not instantly become a fully independent Court of Common Pleas. Their appointment nevertheless marked an important stage in the development of a more regular central bench that could conduct judicial work when the king was elsewhere.
Royal justice therefore developed in two connected directions:
Itinerant justices carried royal authority into the counties
while
central judges provided greater continuity at Westminster
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
Magna Carta 1215 and the Administration of Justice
The expansion of royal government also raised questions about the limits within which royal power should be exercised.
These tensions became particularly serious during the reign of King John, who ruled from 1199 to 1216.
John lost Normandy and other important territories in France. His unsuccessful attempts to recover them required money, while his methods of raising revenue and exercising royal authority generated opposition among powerful barons, who were leading landholders with substantial political influence.
Following military failure in 1214, that opposition developed into rebellion. John and the rebel barons negotiated at Runnymede, where the settlement dated 15 June 1215 became known as Magna Carta, meaning Great Charter.
Its Original Purpose
Magna Carta was not designed as a modern constitution or a universal statement of human rights.
Most of its provisions dealt with practical medieval concerns, including the Church, feudal obligations, debt, taxation, trade, royal forests and the administration of justice. Its immediate purpose was to address a political crisis between the king and leading members of the realm.
Nevertheless, the Charter expressed an important idea: royal authority was expected to operate within recognised legal limits.
Clauses 17, 39 and 40
In the standard modern numbering, three provisions are particularly relevant to the history of royal justice.
Clause 17 required common pleas to be heard in a fixed place rather than following the travelling royal court. This supported the development of a permanent central court for ordinary civil litigation.
Clause 39 restricted serious action against a free man unless it was taken through lawful judgment or the law of the land. It did not create the complete modern right to trial by jury or modern due process in 1215.
Clause 40 promised that justice would not be sold, denied or delayed.
These provisions later acquired a much broader constitutional reputation than they possessed at the time.
Reissues and Later Importance
The 1215 settlement failed quickly. Pope Innocent III annulled the Charter within ten weeks, and armed conflict resumed.
After John's death, revised versions were issued during the reign of Henry III in 1216, 1217 and 1225. A confirmation under Edward I in 1297 gave the later version statutory form.
Magna Carta did not create common law, Parliament, jury trial or modern human rights in one moment. Its importance developed over centuries as lawyers and political thinkers used it to support the principle that public power should be exercised according to law.
For the history of common law, it is especially important because it both reflected concern about the exercise of royal justice and strengthened the movement of common pleas towards a fixed institutional home.
During the thirteenth century, different branches of royal judicial business became increasingly identifiable as separate central courts.
This process was gradual. The courts were not created together by one statute, and their jurisdictions changed over later centuries.
Court
Early principal role
Court of Common Pleas, also called the Common Bench
Dealt mainly with civil disputes between private parties. Magna Carta's requirement that common pleas remain in a fixed place supported its permanent establishment at Westminster.
Court of King's Bench
Developed from judicial business conducted before the king and became particularly associated with serious criminal matters, the King's peace—public order protected through royal authority—and cases affecting the Crown.
Court of Exchequer
Grew from the administration of royal finance and initially dealt especially with disputes concerning revenue owed to the Crown.
The courts later used procedures and legal devices that allowed their work to overlap. Their early functions should therefore not be treated as permanent limits on everything they could eventually hear.
Why Permanent Courts Mattered
Permanent institutions gave royal justice greater continuity. Judges and officials repeatedly handled similar disputes, maintained records and developed specialised procedures.
Combined with the itinerant system, they connected central and local justice:
Central courts developed and administered royal procedures
while
travelling justices applied royal authority in the counties
This combination helped common law become an organised system rather than a series of occasional personal interventions by the monarch.
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
Common Law Becomes an Established National System
By the late twelfth and thirteenth centuries, English royal justice had become sufficiently widespread and organised for a recognisable common law to emerge.
This development rested on several connected changes:
itinerant justices extended royal justice into the counties;
circuits organised the movement of those judges;
royal measures such as the Assize of Clarendon strengthened common procedures;
writs created recurring routes into the king's courts; and
central courts gave royal justice permanent institutional foundations.
The late twelfth-century treatise commonly known as Glanvill provides important evidence of this development. Its full title is usually translated as Treatise on the Laws and Customs of the Kingdom of England. It described procedures used in the royal courts near the end of Henry II's reign. Its authorship is uncertain, so it should not simply be described as a book written personally by Ranulf de Glanvill.
The existence of this treatise does not mean that England had acquired one complete legal code. It does show that royal procedures had become organised enough to be described as a connected body of law.
The Crown and litigants could both benefit from the growth of royal justice. Litigants gained access to procedures that could offer effective remedies, while the Crown gained authority, information and revenue from legal business.
Local, manorial and Church courts continued to operate. Common law became national because the king's courts administered an increasingly shared law across the realm, not because every other legal institution immediately disappeared.
Sources used4 sources
Paul Brand, ‘Henry II and the Creation of the English Common Law’ in Christopher Harper-Bill and Nicholas Vincent (eds), Henry II: New Interpretations (Boydell Press 2007)
John Hudson, The Oxford History of the Laws of England, Volume II: 871–1216 (Oxford University Press 2012)
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
The expression common law is used in more than one way. The intended meaning depends on context.
Context
Meaning
Medieval legal history
The body of royal law and procedure that became increasingly common to England through the king's courts.
Modern sources of law
Law developed through judicial decisions, usually contrasted with legislation enacted by Parliament.
Common law and equity
Common-law rights, rules and remedies can be distinguished from the equitable principles and remedies examined in Note 3.
These meanings are connected, but they are not identical.
Judicial Decisions and Precedent
As royal courts heard similar disputes, judicial reasoning naturally contributed to legal development. Decisions were recorded and discussed, and later lawyers drew upon earlier cases.
This did not mean that Henry II created the modern doctrine of binding precedent.
Medieval judges valued consistency and could refer to earlier decisions, but the strict doctrine under which lower courts are legally bound by applicable decisions of higher courts developed much later. The doctrine took its more modern form alongside improved law reporting and a clearer court hierarchy, and was consolidated particularly during the nineteenth century.
Whether a decision is binding depends on matters including the court hierarchy and the part of the judgment that establishes the relevant legal rule.
Vardarax case comparison
When the House of Lords changed its mind
Anderton v Ryan
[1985] AC 560 · House of Lords · Lord Bridge of Harwich
her purchase of the recorder was a perfectly proper commercial transaction.
The court assumed the video recorder had not been stolen. The majority held that buying it in the belief that it was stolen did not amount to attempted handling.
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
The Limitations of Common Law and the Transition to Equity
The procedures that made common law more organised could also become restrictive.
As the writ system matured, a claim generally had to fit a recognised form of action, meaning an established procedural route. The chosen form could affect pleading, proof and the remedy available. A genuine grievance might therefore fail if the wrong route was used or no suitable form existed.
The same standardisation that promoted certainty could consequently limit flexibility. Note 3 examines these problems in greater detail.
Over time, people who could not obtain adequate relief through the ordinary common-law process could petition the king or the King's Council. Responsibility for some of this work became associated with the Lord Chancellor.
By the fourteenth century, the Chancellor's work had begun to extend beyond administration towards the regular resolution of disputes. This developing jurisdiction became the institutional basis of the principles and remedies known as equity.
Equity did not replace common law. It developed alongside it to provide additional legal responses in recognised circumstances.
This is the point at which Note 2 leads into Note 3:
Common law creates shared courts and procedures
↓
Those procedures promote consistency but can become restrictive
↓
Petitions seek relief beyond the ordinary common-law process
↓
Chancery develops a judicial role and equity emerges
Sources used3 sources
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
Lucy Jones, Introduction to Business Law (6th edn, Oxford University Press 2025) ch 1
Overall Significance
English common law emerged through a long process rather than through the work of one monarch.
Norman centralisation supplied important political and administrative foundations. Henry I strengthened royal administration, while the Anarchy demonstrated the problems created when central authority weakened. Henry II then greatly expanded and organised royal justice through judges, circuits, inquests and writs.
During the late twelfth and thirteenth centuries, travelling justice and permanent courts developed together. Magna Carta challenged particular uses of royal power and supported the permanent location of common pleas. Common Pleas, King's Bench and Exchequer gradually became distinct central courts.
The result was not a complete written code or the immediate disappearance of local law. It was an increasingly coherent body of royal rules and procedures capable of operating across England.
The development can be summarised as follows:
Norman government strengthens the Crown
↓
Henry I develops royal administration
↓
The Anarchy weakens central authority
↓
Henry II expands and organises royal justice
↓
Itinerant justices, writs and central courts make royal law increasingly national
↓
Common law becomes an established legal system
↓
Its procedural limitations help prepare the way for equity
Henry II should therefore be described as a central figure in the emergence of English common law, not as its sole inventor.
Research trail
Sources and further reading
A complete list of linked material used throughout this note, followed by any additional reading recorded by Vardarax.
Sources used32 sources throughout this note
Lucy Jones, Introduction to Business Law (6th edn, Oxford University Press 2025) ch 1
F W Maitland, The Forms of Action at Common Law (Cambridge University Press 1909)
Paul Brand, ‘Henry II and the Creation of the English Common Law’ in Christopher Harper-Bill and Nicholas Vincent (eds), Henry II: New Interpretations (Boydell Press 2007)
John Hudson, The Oxford History of the Laws of England, Volume II: 871–1216 (Oxford University Press 2012)
Paul Brand, ‘Judges and Judging 1176–1307’ in Paul Brand and Joshua Getzler (eds), Judges and Judging in the History of the Common Law and Civil Law (Cambridge University Press 2012)